An entirely preventable problem: Misinformation, online marketplaces, delivery riders & illegal bikes
A new survey of delivery riders has laid bare the scale of illegal e-moto use in the gig economy – and its impact – as well as offering a rare insight into riders’ lives.
Electrical Safety First, along with UCL, interviewed 637 delivery riders online, and 20 in-person. The aim was to understand and tackle what was driving non-compliant battery fires, from illegal e-motos commonly used in the gig economy. Their findings, in Powering the UK Gig Economy Safely: Tackling E-Bike Fire Risks for Food Delivery Riders, is there to raise wider questions.
In 2019 there were 10 PLV (private light vehicle) battery fires in the UK – which includes e-scooters and eBikes. By 2025 it was 432 and the problem continues to grow.
While the drumbeat of fire risk from dodgy batteries is becoming deafening, the voices of those at risk are not. Report author, Tatianna Rodrigues, of Electrical Safety First, highlighted this ‘invisible workforce’ that ‘goes out in all weathers’ to bring people food at home. She said, ‘reflected in the data and policy, they are almost invisible’ – i.e., ‘nobody can tell us how many of those fires involved delivery riders’. That’s why researchers asked about the riders’ lives, their work, living arrangements and backgrounds. The resulting report gives a rare voice to those riders.
The language in the report is problematic because we know fires come from after-market modifications and non-compliant equipment, rather than compliant e-cycles, often rendering them illegal e-motos in the eyes of the law. The reputational damage to the industry has been devastating, to put it bluntly. So the use of ‘eBikes’, while understandable, isn’t ideal.
Terminology aside, this research is vital. It finds delivery drivers are consistently at risk from battery fires from these products, with dangerous practices widespread across the workforce multiplying the risks.
Of the riders surveyed, 17% said they had modified their bikes, and more than a quarter said those machines could exceed the legal speed limit. 21% said they used a converted pedal cycle, rather than a manufactured eBike – a low-cost, but riskier option. Echoing what we know about dangerous products coming not from high street retailers, a third bought a new bike online, 28% from a dealer, and 18% second-hand.
Striking from the interview snippets was the level of misinformation circulating among riders around what constitutes safe, legal equipment, and the difficulties in accessing accurate safety information.
On the basics, some riders thought 30mph was the legal limit for an eBike (electric assistance above 15.5mph constitutes an e-motorbike); others didn’t realise swapping batteries and chargers, or using a faulty battery was dangerous.
The survey found riders with modified bikes were statistically more likely to report having battery issues such as overheating (16% vs 9% for unmodified bikes) and that their bike went 20 mph or higher (26% vs 17% for unmodified).
While 73% of riders are concerned about potential battery fires, more than half – 52% – charge batteries in living areas and 39% charge overnight, or otherwise unattended. This was often because there was no alternative, in crowded accommodation after a long day on the road. Riders reported charging batteries in their bedroom while they slept, others in hallways, blocking escape routes in the event of a fire. One said explicitly ‘that is my job… you have to accept that.’
Unsafe practices ‘widespread’
If the written responses were eye-opening, the photos riders submitted were something else. While riders reported their bikes hadn’t been modified, more than half were in fact conversions (it’s likely they just didn’t realise). ESF analysed the 96 submitted images and found 26% were converted pedal cycles and 17.8% modified e-cycles. Photos showed conventional pedal cycles with multiple batteries attached, wires protruding, and oversized motors. Seven included products ESF suspects to be safety recalls, such as the notorious UPP U004 battery. Added to these hazards were extra batteries bolted on, replacement chargers and exposed cables. ESF said: “Across the images submitted, a consistent pattern emerged: unsafe practices are widespread, normalised, and closely linked to the structural conditions in which riders live and work.”
At the launch of this report in Parliament this week, Rodrigues and a colleague described their shock not only at the dangerous products, but vehicles pictured charging beside radiators, or beside even riskier machines. It is conceivable these practices are happening in bedrooms and overcrowded housing in cities across the UK.
A damning indictment of a broken system
Riders were recruited through a single major delivery app platform, boosting response numbers from 90-odd before their involvement, to over 600. While they are to be commended for this openness, in the end, the platform wanted to remain anonymous.
You can understand why. The results are a damning indictment of the system they operate. As the report put it, ‘these accounts suggest that fire risk awareness is not absent but is unevenly distributed and often outweighed by economic necessity.’
Other stakeholders interviewed by ESF, from central and local government to emergency services, linked economic pressures and long hours, with poor rider choice. ‘They are looking to get the cheapest solution to work as long and as fast as they can’ said one central government participant. An emergency service participant said ‘gig economy companies are doing just a bare minimum where profit margins are still skyrocketing’. A platform representative was quoted as saying while they have a responsibility to provide awareness, riders can ‘choose not to take us up on it’.
Recommendations
The report sets out recommendations, starting with the gig economy. We need to close the loophole that classes riders as self-employed, it says. Riders who are employees are less likely to purchase dodgy equipment, we were told in Parliament. Delivery companies need to provide mandatory health and safety training for riders around battery and fire safety. At the moment riders find information from a range of sources that includes peers, and TikTok, much of which will be incorrect. One rider cheerfully explained that they bought a rapid charger that could fully charge a battery in 90 minutes – which ESF clearly identified as a fire risk. Many didn’t know where you dispose of an old or damaged or dangerous battery.
It says battery and online marketplace regulation needs to improve, too. ESF regularly scours marketplaces and reports suspect products, which are taken down only to be re-listed under a different name later on. I stood with Cycling Electric editor, Mark Sutton, after the Parliamentary event. He input ‘ebike conversion’ into Amazon’s search bar and, scrolling down, told me: ‘none of these products are legal’.
Safe charging points, where batteries can be recharged in secure cabinets away from homes, are needed, too, as seen in New York. The report recommends improved battery disposal and recall systems, to take dangerous products out of people’s homes and off the road. Finally, researchers want to see better data collection on battery fires, especially related to delivery riders – so those riders aren’t invisible any more.
It doesn’t end at the gig economy. A substantial 6% of the UK public now own a (private light electric vehicle) or PLEV, of which e-scooters are a part. Many of these will be non-compliant products, and as such 14% of owners have experienced a safety issue with the battery or charger. Also concerning was that 23% had bought a battery replacement or charger, known fire risk factors.
Zooming out it is increasingly clear we are all picking up the tab for ‘innovators’ like delivery app firms and online marketplaces; companies making enormous profits.
Riders bear the cost of these business practices, in heightened risk of fire and collisions. Risks extend to those who share a roof with the owners of dodgy machines, or share the road with them. Professor of Transport Safety at UCL, Nicola Christie, summed up the gig economy: ‘Everything we know about road safety, this system is working against it.’
The cost extends to the emergency services picking up the pieces, from fires and collisions, and in trying to track down dodgy products before they cause calamity.
One comment, from an emergency services participant, said: ‘If a county police force was to seize as many [illegal eBikes] as the Met did last year, they would bankrupt all of their garages’.
And then there’s the impact on the cycle industry. At the Parliamentary launch, Bicycle Association Chair, Phillip Darnton, underscored the reputational damage undermining an industry with 60,000 employees, whose uptake of eBikes lags far behind our European counterparts. After multiple reports, and eight years of sounding the alarm, it’s time for government action, he said – adding the Trust Mark, “E-bike Positive doesn’t even begin to solve the problem”. The Product Safety and Metrology Bill, designed to tackle dangerous products online, awaits its secondary legislation, when Parliamentary time allows. Until then potentially lethal products will continue to be taken down from online marketplaces, only to reappear three days later; police and firefighters will pick up the pieces and delivery riders remain on the front line of an entirely preventable problem.
Laura Laker is author of the All Party Parliamentary Report on ‘fake e-bikes’, published last year. https://appgcw.org/resources/inquiries/unregulated-and-unsafe-the-threat-of-illegal-e-bikes/

